Building Law Monthly
Absence of contract denied adjudicator jurisdiction
In Serapid Ltd v Octavius Infrastructure Ltd [2026] EWHC 2695 (TCC) Moody J held that, on an examination of the documentary evidence, the parties to the present litigation had not entered into a binding contract and, as a consequence, the adjudicator did not have jurisdiction to decide the dispute which had been referred to him.
Given that the existence or otherwise of a binding contract was held to be an “intensely fact sensitive” question, the precedent
value of the present case is limited. But it does act as a reminder of the need to ensure, as far as possible, that the question
whether or not the parties have entered into a contractual relationship is tested as thoroughly as possible before adjudication
is commenced. As the present case demonstrates, the conclusion that no contract was entered into will operate to derive the
adjudicator of jurisdiction and so deprive the decision of the adjudicator of legal effect.