Lloyd's Shipping & Trade Law
Security is not suit, and deck cargo must be identified
Batavia Eximp & Contracting (S) Pte Ltd v Pedregal Maritime SA (The Taikoo Brilliance) [2026] EWCA Civ 1158.
Cargo claims are lost as much by procedural missteps as by bad facts. Arresting a ship and obtaining security will not stop
the Hague-Visby clock unless substantive proceedings are brought in time. Nor will a loose deck-cargo notation remove part
of a mixed cargo from the Rules: where the goods differ in value, the bill of lading must say which cargo is on deck. The
Court of Appeal answers two points of real practical importance. First, proceedings brought only to obtain security are not
“suit” for article III rule 6. Secondly, where only part of a non-homogeneous cargo is to be deck cargo, article I(c) requires
identification of that part, not merely a quantity or proportion.