Insurance Law Monthly
Causation: concurrent causes
As a result of the root decision in Wayne Tank & Pump Co Ltd v Employers’ Liability Assurance Corporation Ltd [1973] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 237 it is settled law in England that if a loss has two causes – whether they be independent (in that each could alone have caused the loss) or interdependent (in that the two causes worked together to cause the loss) – there is no recovery if either of the two causes is the subject of an express policy exclusion. By contrast, if there is an insured and an uninsured cause, the insured cause prevails. A different approach to concurrent causes may be found in Canada, most recently in the decision of the Ontario Court of Appeal in Green Rise Foods Inc v NV Hagelunie 2026 ONCA 334.
Green Rise: the facts
Green Rise grew tomatoes as part of its large greenhouse operation. It used boilers in its greenhouse both to provide heat
and to generate carbon dioxide for promoting the growth of the tomato crop. The boilers produced “flue gas”, a part of which
was extracted and introduced to a condenser unit which reduced the temperature and moisture of the gas. The condenser unit
was equipped with a Sercom Monitor which measured the level of carbon monoxide in the flue gas. When the boilers were functioning
property, the flue gas contained only safe levels of carbon monoxide, but if the level became unsafe then the monitor set
off an alarm and also vented the unsafe carbon monoxide out of the greenhouse.