Insurance Law Monthly
Property insurance: increase of risk and fire exclusion
In Bellshill Property Ltd v Borland Insurance Ltd [2026] CSOH 71, Lord Sandison in the Outer House of the Court of Session considered whether a trial should be allowed to proceed in circumstances where a landlord was claiming against its tenant and its insurance broker for loss of a warehouse by fire. The insurers had avoided liability under the policy and the question was whether the broker or tenant had been at fault. That involved consideration as to whether there would have been coverage under the policy but for the conduct of the broker and tenant. Two clauses fell to be reviewed: an increase of risk clause; and a fire exclusion.
Belshill: the facts
Belshill was the owner of a large warehouse unit, which was leased to Tradebe and used for the purpose of processing clinical
waste. GTM, the parent company of Tradebe, guaranteed Tradebe's liabilities under the lease. Belshill was, under the lease,
required to insure the unit against various risks, including fire, and GTM was required to pay the premium. Under the lease,
Tradebe was obliged not to do anything that might invalidate the insurance coverage and not to do anything that might cause
an increase in premium without paying additional premium.