TOPTIP HOLDING PTE LTD v MERCURIA ENERGY TRADING PTE LTD (THE “PAN GOLD”)
 1 Lloyd's Rep. 316
COURT OF APPEAL OF SINGAPORE
Before Chief Justice Menon,Judge of Appeal Phang Boon Leong,Judge of Appeal Prakash
Contract – Formation – Negotiations for charter of vessel – Owners’ offer expressed to be “Subject to review” of charterer's pro forma charterparty “with logical amendment” – Whether binding contract concluded – Whether any concluded contract void for uncertainty.