Trusts and Estates
IHT – gifts with reservation of benefit – further thought on Buzzoni v HMRC
Late in 2013 the Court of Appeal allowed the taxpayer’s appeal in Buzzoni v HMRC [2013] EWA Civ 1684. Both the First Tier
Tribunal and the Upper Tribunal upheld the Revenue contention that there had been a Gift With Reservation of Benefit, so it
is worth studying the Court of Appeal’s reasons for deciding, that after all, there was no reservation of benefit. The judgment
of Moses LJ, with whom Black and Gloster LJJ agreed, is not always easy to follow, but that is to an extent due to the complications
involved in the conveyancing of leasehold flats. As in Ingram v IRC (1999) STC 37 a major issue revolved around the issue
of regarding leasehold and freehold interests in a particular property as being separate proprietary interests, though in
the event that turned out not to be the deciding factor. What should be noted, however, is that this was not a case where
the deceased sought to remain in occupation of the property under a relatively short-term interest, so the legislation, in
s102A to 102C Finance Act 1986 intended to counter the “leasehold carve-out” would not be applicable.