ISLANDER SHIPPING ENTERPRISES S.A. v. EMPRESA MARITIMA DEL ESTADO S.A. (THE "KHIAN SEA")
                                                                    [1977] 2 Lloyd's Rep 439
                                                                    QUEEN'S BENCH DIVISION(COMMERCIAL COURT)
                                                                    Before Mr. Justice Donaldson
                                                                    
Charter-party (Time)-Safe berth-Vessel ordered to berth in Valparaiso-Berth exposed to heavy swell-Vessel unable to leave berth because of presence of two other vessels which had anchored sufficiently close to wharf-Vessel suffered ranging damage-Whether charterers liable-New York Produce Exchange form.