International Construction Law Review
OBSERVATIONS ON THE FIDIC CONSTRUCTION SUBCONTRACT 2011 – PART I1
Götz-Sebastian Hök2, Germany
Siobhan Fahey3, Ireland4
In late 2011 FIDIC published the FIDIC Subcontract for Construction, First Edition (in this paper referred to as the “FIDIC Subcontract”). This FIDIC form addresses the normal arrangement where under the sub-contractor is employed by the contractor in the construction of the subcontract works in accordance with the design details provided by the employer under the main contract5. This subcontract document was prepared by FIDIC for use where the main contract is based on the FIDIC Conditions of Contract for Construction 1999 (in this paper referred to as the “main contract”). If it is to be used where the main contract is based on the FIDIC Multilateral Development Bank harmonised edition, then necessary amendments are needed to reflect the significant differences between this harmonised edition and the FIDIC Conditions of Contract for Construction 1999.
1. INTRODUCTION – SUBCONTRACTS GENERALLY
A subcontract is a separate and integral contract between a main contractor and a sub-contractor but is an ancillary contract – it cannot exist independently and depends on the existence of a main contract. Both contracts are aimed at achieving the same objective or have a common subset of objectives. Subcontracts may be used for a great variety of services, for example: the execution and completion of permanent subcontract works, the design and/or the operation or maintenance of the subcontract works as well as mere supply of goods and materials or combined supply and assembly of equipment and plant. The procurement of subcontracts
1 This paper is Part 1 of a two-part paper. Part 2 will be published shortly and will discuss further aspects of the FIDIC Construction Subcontract, including payment, claims and disputes.
2 Sebastian Hök is the current legal advisor of the FIDIC Task Group for the Design & Build Subcontract.
3 Siobhan Fahey is a member of the FIDIC Contracts Committee; a member of the FIDIC Task Group for the Construction Subcontract; and the Chairwoman of the FIDIC Task Group for the Design & Build Subcontract.
4 Both authors express their own personal views on the subject-matter. It should be noted that this paper is not drafted to represent FIDIC views.
5 The FIDIC Subcontract 2011 was the subject of a paper entitled “The FIDIC Subcontract, First Edition” by Emma Kratochvilova and Michael Mendelblat of Herbert Smith LLP, which was previously published by ICLR in 2012 at pages 46 et seq and may be of interest to readers.
326