Charter-party (Voyage) - Laytime - Lightening operation - Laytime and demurrage only to apply to discharging from lightening vessels - Four lightening vessels used - Calculation of laytime.
Practice - Summary judgment - Claim in respect of demurrage - Defendants denied they were a party to charter-party - Whether defendants should have been given unconditional leave to defend - Whether defendants should be granted leave to produce further evidence.
Practice - Summary judgment - Sale of goods by ship's tanks composite sample - Construction of contract and telex messages - Whether defendants entitled to appeal against summary judgment.
Practice - Application to set aside - Service of writ out of jurisdiction - Defendant's solicitors agreed to accept service - Whether agreement sufficient of itself to establish jurisdiction - Whether discretion properly exercised in setting aside service of writ.
Banking - Guarantee - Summary judgment - Defendants gave personal guarantee - Bank applied for summary judgment - Defendants pleaded collateral agreement that guarantee would not be enforced - Defendants given conditional leave to defend - Whether bank entitled to summary judgment - Whether defendants entitled to unconditional leave to defend.
Navigation - Passenger steamer - Sailing vessel used for excursions - Yawl carrying more than 12 persons - Passengers including young persons - Yawl unable to operate under sail without passengers participation - Whether vessel required to have a certificate of survey - Whether young persons engaged on board ship on business of ship - Merchant Shipping Act, 1894, s. 271, as amended by Merchant Shipping Act, 1964, s. 17 and Merchant Shipping Act, 1979, Schedule 6 - Merchant Shipping (Safety Convention) Act, 1949, s. 26 (1) (a).
Charter-party (Voyage) - Demurrage - Strike action caused congestion at loading port - Export of crude oil banned - Arbitrators found charter frustrated - Whether vessel came on demurrage - Whether owners entitled to claim demurrage.
Practice - Banking - Summary judgment - Bank sought to recover loans made to plaintiffs - Whether triable issues raised on affidavits - Whether bank entitled to summary judgment - Whether plaintiffs had arguable defence - R.S.C., O. 14.
Reinsurance - Indemnity - Vessel constructive total loss - Reinsurance placed by broker before original insurance - Whether reinsurers liable - Whether brokers in breach of duty of care - Legal effect of signing indication.
Banking - Guarantee - Purchase of cargo of cement - Credit manager of bank gave undertaking to return moneys - Cargo rejected - Whether plaintiffs could claim on undertaking - Whether bank liable.
Admiralty practice - Action in rem - Vessel ordered to be appraised and sold - Bunkers on board vessel - Whether intervener/charterers of vessel could claim proceeds of sale of bunkers.
Charter-party (Time) - Carriage by sea - Roll-on roll-off vessel - Charterers unable to load double stacked 40 ft. containers on mafi trailers - Whether owners in breach of charter-party - Whether owners could rely on clause in charter.
Collision - Crossing vessels - Collision in narrow channel - Whether vessels at fault in navigating channel - Liability for collision - Apportionment of blame.
Charter-party (Time) - Safe port - Vessel ordered to bunkering place within port - Vessel took ground - Whether owners could recover costs of repair and hire from charterers - Whether port a safe port - Whether refinery had authority to decide where vessel should bunker.
Insurance (Fire) - Conspiracy - Premises destroyed by fire and explosion - Whether destruction caused by conspiracy - Whether breach of policy conditions occurred - Whether policy void - Whether value of premises its market price or replacement costs.
Insurance (Marine) - Sue and labour clause - Plaintiffs insured intermodal freight containers - Containers leased to lessee - Lessee adjudged bankrupt - Plaintiffs recovered leased containers - Whether plaintiffs could claim recovery costs under policy - Whether sue and labour clause applicable.
Admiralty practice - Action in rem - Renewal of writ - Extension of validity of writ - Admiralty Registrar extended validity and renewed writ - Whether Admiralty Registrar in error in making order.
Admiralty practice - Stay of action - Bill of lading - Exclusive jurisdiction clause - Non-delivery of container and contents - Whether action should have been brought in Denmark - Whether action should be stayed.
Collision - Apportionment of liability - Collision at Tartous Harbour - Vessels collided with each other and with barges - Whether reasonable care and skill exercised by masters of vessels - Liability for collision.
Charter-party (Time) - War risks insurance - Iran-Iraq war - Arabian Gulf declared an additional premium area - Vessel entered Gulf - Owners paid additional premiums to Club - Whether owners could recover premiums from charterers - Whether premiums excessive.
Charter-party (Time) - Bill of lading - Indemnity - Cargo delivered to receivers without protection of bill of lading - Vessel arrested - Owners suffered loss of earnings and other expenses - Whether owners entitled to be indemnified by charterers for such loss - Whether express or implied right to indemnity arose under charter.
Arbitration - Award - Arbitrator - Misconduct - Arbitrator appeared to overlook agreement that issue to stand over - Whether interim award should be set aside or remitted - Whether arbitrator should be removed.
Reinsurance - Illegality - Ratification - Whether original contracts made without plaintiffs' ostensible authority - Whether contracts validly ratified - Whether plaintiffs had insurable interest on which to recover reinsurance - Whether contracts illegal by virtue of Insurance Companies Act, 1974 and 1981.
Carriage by air - Limitation of liability - Warsaw Convention - Loss of cargo - Whether limitation provisions enforceable in United States Court - Unit of account to be used to convert judgments into U.S. dollars - Warsaw Convention arts. 18, 22 - United States.
Sale of goods (c.i.f.) - Non-acceptance - Buyers rejected goods tendered - Goods did not comply with contractual description - Whether certificate of quality and inspection conclusive - Whether buyers entitled to reject goods.
Admiralty practice - Action in rem - Damage to cargo - Ad hoc arbitration agreement entered into - Vessel arrested - Security provided for release of vessel - Affidavit did not disclose arbitration in existence - Whether security should be discharged.
Charter-party (Time) - Safe port - Cancellation - Iran-Iraq war - Vessel ordered to proceed to Basrah - Whether charterers in breach of obligation to trade between safe ports - Whether charterers entitled to cancel charter.
Sale of ship - Stay of action - Vessel sold to Taiwanese buyers - Buyers refused to accept vessel - Sellers alleged wrongful inducement and conspiracy by Taiwanese broker - Whether Court of Taiwan natural and proper forum for resolution of dispute - Whether part of general endorsement on writ should be struck out - Whether application for stay should be granted.
Insurance (Aviation) - Reinsurance - Slip policy - Indemnity - DC 10 airline crashed near Paris - Syndicate 619 paid out in respect of loss - Whether loss covered by reinsurance slip policy - Whether Syndicate 619 could recover under excess of loss reinsurance policy.
Practice - Mareva injunction - Alleged creditor obtained injunction - Whether creditor should be allowed to intervene in an action with which he was not concerned.
Arbitration - Interest - Whether claim for excess interest referred to arbitration - Whether claim assigned so reference to arbitration ineffective - Whether too later for arbitrator to make award.
Agency - Commission - Shipowners fell behind with payments due to agents in Saudi Arabia - Agents claimed moneys due - Rate of exchange applicable-Whether interest could be recovered- Whether agents entitled to sums claimed.
Arbitration - Award - Performance of charter guaranteed by defendants - Difficulties in collection of hire - Incorporated agreement entered into - Dispute referred to arbitration - Award against charterers not honoured - Whether owners' cause of action merged with award - Whether owners could claim under guarantee - Whether owners trustees for commission due to charterers' brokers.
Arbitration - Award - Interest - Charterers made an "open offer" - Owners eventually accepted offer - Umpire awarded interest on demurrage and freight - Whether umpire had power to award such interest - Whether compound interest could be awarded - Whether umpire considered effect of open offer - Whether umpire should be removed.
Arbitration - Award - Further reasons - Sale of goods (c. & f.) - Arbitrators found in favour of buyers - Whether application for order that arbitrators should state further reasons should be granted - Arbitration Act, 1979, s. 1 (5).
Carriage by sea - Limitation of liability - Cargo arrived in deteriorated condition - Whether carriers could rely on contractual limitation - Whether Hague-Visby Rules applied - Carriage of Goods by Sea Act, 1971.
Carriage by sea - Bill of lading - Limitation of time - Damage to cargoes - Whether extension of time had been granted - Whether defendant estopped from denying that extension granted - Whether claim time barred.
Bill of lading - "Himalaya" clause - Proceedings brought against stevedore for damage caused to container - Whether proceedings begun within time - Whether stevedore could rely on protection given to carriers in bill of lading - Australia.
Collision - Stay of action - Turkish owners brought action against Cuban owners in Turkish Courts - Cuban owners commenced action in England - Whether English action should be stayed - Whether Turkey a more natural forum.
Charter-party (Consecutive Voyage)-Rectification- Escalation clause - Unilateral mistake - Clause provided for a base figure in U.S. dollars to be increased by reference to Italian inflation - Whether plaintiffs aware that base figure expressed in U.S. dollars instead of Italian lire - Whether unilateral mistake - Whether clause should be rectified.
Charter-party (Voyage) - Laytime - Shifting expenses - Whether laytime counted during period vessel waiting for berth - Whether charterers liable for expense of hiring tugboats to keep vessel in place at berth - Whether charterers liable for shifting expenses.
Conflict of laws - Sovereign immunity - Sale of goods to foreign state - Judgment obtained against state - Whether states' London bank accounts could be garnisheed - State Immunity Act, 1978.
Charter-party (Voyage) - Rectification - Brokers arranged fixture of vessel - Whether name of owners in charter could be rectified - Whether charter binding on company named in charter.
Charter-party (Voyage) - Demurrage - Receivers paid half demurrage claim - Charter signed by plaintiffs - Whether plaintiffs agents for receivers - Whether plaintiffs liable for demurrage - Whether injunction restraining defendants from proceeding with arbitration should be granted.
Arbitration - Award - Safe port warranty - Vessel ordered to Beirut - Arbitrator found charterers in breach of safe port warranty - Whether arbitrator had erred in his decision.
Arbitration - Award - Remission - Whether errors in award - Whether award could be corrected under s. 17 - Whether award should be remitted - Arbitration Act, 1950, s. 17.
Carriage by sea - Damage to cargo - Cargo discharged into trucks or lighters - Whether damage caused between loading and discharging - Extent of damage - Quantum of damage.
Arbitration - Award - Remission - Special case did not include general questions of law to enable all points of law to be argued - Whether contract of sale governed by English law - Whether award should be remitted.
Insurance (Extraneous Damage) - Policy - Damage to crane - Whether crane insured under policy - Whether material change in risk - Whether loss attributable to extraneous cause - Whether all governmental and other regulations complied with - Whether assured could recover under the policy.
Sale of goods (c. & f.) - Non-delivery - Export of silver banned - Whether force majeure clause and buyers' standard terms incorporated - Whether contracts frustrated - Whether buyers notified under force majeure clause - Whether buyers entitled to damages.
Sale of goods (c. & f.) - Rejection - Vessel deviated from direct route - Buyers rejected goods and claimed refund - Whether buyers entitled to reject goods - Whether buyers had waived their right to reject.
Sale of goods (c.i.f.) - Non-delivery - Prohibition of export - Sellers failed to deliver - Whether sellers had made out a defence under the prohibition clause - GAFTA 100.
Practice - Stay of action - Jurisdiction - Guarantee - Bank claimed under guarantee - Defendants commenced action in Greece - Whether English Court had jurisdiction to hear case - Whether action should be stayed - Whether application to stay proceedings should be heard first.
Arbitration - Award - Enforcement - Award in favour of plaintiffs made in Kuwait - Whether award a Convention award - Whether award could be enforced - Arbitration Act, 1975, ss. 1, 7 (1).
Admiralty practice - Action in rem - Warrant of arrest - Application to set aside warrant and writ - Whether action lay outside jurisdiction of High Court - Whether application should be granted.
Practice - Banking - Summary judgment - Bank sought to recover loans made to plaintiffs - Whether triable issues raised on affidavits - Whether bank entitled to summary judgment - Whether plaintiffs had arguable defence - R.S.C., O. 14.
Arbitration - Award - Remission - Misconduct - Whether arbitrator guilty of technical misconduct - Whether arbitrator erred in law - Whether leave to appeal should be granted - Whether further reasons should be stated - Measure of damage - Whether reference to Court of Justice should be granted.
Banking - Duty of care - Forged cheques - Extent of duty owed by customer to bank - True effect of bank's rules for current accounts - Whether bank entitled to debit forged cheques to customers account.
Charter-party (Time) - Redelivery - Option to narrow redelivery period - Charterers exercised option late - Whether option validly exercised - Whether charter took effect as one for five years precisely.
Carriage by sea - Charter-party (Time) - Lightening operation at port in India - Damage caused to lightened vessel by lightening vessel - Negligent navigation - Whether United States Carriage of Goods by Sea Act incorporated in charter - Whether effect confined to voyages to and from United States ports - Whether owners exempt from liability to charterers for damage caused to vessel - United States Carriage of Goods by Sea Act, 1936 s. 4 (2).
Practice - Multiple proceedings - Injunction - Proceedings commenced in England and New York - Whether injunction restraining proceedings in New York should be granted - Whether fact that English proceedings might be heard first to be taken into account in exercise of discretion.
Sale of goods (f.o.b.) - Quantum of damages - Defendants liable for wrongful repudiation of contract - Damages assessed upon difference between contract price and market price on last trading day of contract - Whether such assessment true measure of damage.
Charter-party (Time) - Liability - Damages - Vessel's crew and officers Filipinos - I.T.F. stopped discharge of vessel - Whether vessel "fitted for service" - Whether owners in breach of charter - Whether charterers' losses on sub-charter to be taken into account on assessment of damages.
Charter-party (Time)-Hire-Letter of undertaking given by bank - Owners claimed under letter of undertaking-Whether sums claimed charter hire- Whether charterers' liability for hire could be set off against owners' liability for bunkers on redelivery.
Charter-party (Time) - Arbitration clause - Charter governed by Spanish law - Whether arbitration clause valid under Spanish law - Whether injunction restraining charterers from proceeding with arbitration should be granted.
Arbitration - Award - Remission - Errors of law - Obligation to insure mortgaged vessel - Arbitrators stated award in form of special case - Whether award should be remitted or set aside for errors of law - Valuation of mortgaged vessel - Whether overvalue illegal.
Arbitration - Award - Charter-party - Incorrect dimensions of vessel given to refinery - Vessel delayed in loading - Vessel loaded through one manifold only - Whether owners/charterers in breach - Whether owners/charterers entitled to damages - Whether damages too remote to be recoverable.
Sale of goods (f.o.b.) - Carrying charges - Special term agreed regarding carrying charges - Whether term complied with - Whether sellers could retain carrying charges paid by buyers.
[1984] 1 Lloyd's Rep. 687
Lloyd's and the Lloyd's Crest are trademarks of the Society incorporated by the Lloyd's Act 1871
by the name of Lloyd's
In order to deliver a personalised, responsive service and to improve the site, we remember and store information about how you use it. This is done using simple text files called cookies which sit on your computer. By continuing to use this site and access its features, you are consenting to our use of cookies. To find out more about the way www.i-law.com uses cookies please go to our Cookie Policy page.
By closing this message, you are consenting to our use of cookies.